Menu 0
Previous | Next
Home Gifts Tinned Seafood Mystery Box
Donostia Foods Tinned Seafood Mystery Box Logo
It's a mystery... box.
Tinned Seafood Mystery Box with a Golden Tin Aglow - Donostia Foods
Donostia Foods Tinned Seafood Mystery Box Logo
It's a mystery... box.
Tinned Seafood Mystery Box with a Golden Tin Aglow - Donostia Foods

Tinned Seafood Mystery Box

Donostia Foods

$39.95 – Sold Out

| /

What's inside? It's a mystery.

MYSTERY BOXES... WILL RETURN.

AS YOU MAY KNOW FROM EXPERIENCE, THEY DISAPPEAR QUICKLY. IF YOU'VE BEEN INTRIGUED BY THE MYSTERY AND UNABLE TO GET ONE, PLEASE BE SURE TO SUBSCRIBE TO OUR MAILING LIST TO BE NOTIFIED WHEN OUR NEXT BATCH IS AVAILABLE.

Might you pull one of the golden tins of angulas? Yes! Or perhaps a TREASURE CHEST OF TINS, a box full of only the most sought-after slice of The Beauty of the North, ventresca de Bonito del Norte? Also yes! And some in this fresh batch? They hold a secret.

Five tins of seafood in each box. No matter what, you'll get five tins of deliciousness.

*Please note*: we are not guaranteeing you will get a golden tin or treasure chest. It's a mystery. They are included at reasonable odds for pulling them, with the notion that a mystery box is, at its essence, a random selection of items with the thrill of chance mixed in, and doesn't necessarily always include one of the most expensive tins. Because that's part of the fun.

The batches are limited, so if you'd like to get in on the fun, you should probably order one.

Each box includes 5 tins from our selection of tinned seafood. The mystery box itself is white, and hand stamped. For more fun.

free shipping for orders over $75

SATISFACTION GUARANTEE: If you're not satisfied with your order, simply send us an email within 30 days and we'll replace your order or issue a full refund.

Perhaps You'd Also Enjoy...

Overall rating: 4.923077 / 5 from 39 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

The Tinned Seafood Mystery Box offers a delightful surprise with a variety of high-quality seafood products. Customers appreciate the thrill of the unknown and the satisfaction of the selection. The products are highly praised for their quality and variety, making it a fun and rewarding purchase.

Summary topics

  • Surprise Factor (16%): Many customers stated that the surprise was wonderful and they were delighted with the contents of the box.
  • Product Selection (13%): Customers expressed satisfaction with the selection of products in the box, praising the variety and quality.
  • Product Quality (19%): A significant number of customers raved about the products, praising them as excellent, great, and amazing.

Review topics: [].

Review highlights

  • "Great products, this time I ordered a mystery box and will definitely order from them again!" — Andy
  • "Excellent company, quick shipping and most important quality fish and seafood, thank you!" — James B.
  • "My mystery box arrived quickly and the items I received were well worth the purchase." — Stephen G.

Reviews

I love a good mystery!

"Our extended family are tinned fish fanatics and Donostia has never let us down. I got a hankering for something different and when the 8 AM email came in about the new mystery box offering, I signed up for two. The unboxing was fun and we were well pleased with the offerings. While we did have a little overlap between the boxes (not within) - 2X Ventresca de Atún Claro en Salsa Tikka and 2X Filetes de Caballa en Salsa Teriyaki), we will share those with our in-laws. Aw shoot, we are likely to share some of the singletons, too, when we all get together! Tinfest! I pulled out our well-worn copy of Bart van Olphen's "The Tinned Fish Cookbook" for inspiration. . . Big Fun in the Northern Territories of the Conch Republic!"

— doktar r. (5/5)

My First Mystery Box

"Made an impulse buy on my first mystery box. Did not get the golden eels but I’m am very pleased with the variety I found in my mystery box! As others have said, it had things I probably would not have otherwise tried on my own. Can not wait to enjoy with some of my other Donostia purchases."

— Maya W. (5/5)

Totally Not worth it!… the Mystery is how much money I wasted…

"Limited variety, basically only clams and calamari…my worst purchase from Donostia!"

— Doru L. (5/5)

"Love it"

— Catherine (5/5)

"Excellent products and great customer service. Mystery boxes have been exceptional and a great way to try items you might not order but now you get a chance to decide."

— Stephen (5/5)

Mmmmmmmmnmnmnm soooooooo gooooood…….

"I am never disappointed with the mystery!!! I have to ration the deliciousness! Growing up my father would savor unusual tinned fish at Christmas time and on New Year’s Eve so I have a sentimental sense of magic with each box when they are available!"

— Suzanne N. (5/5)

All bangers!

"All bangers!"

— Aaron B. (5/5)

No mystery to me.

"It's no mystery that everything is top quality and delicious. What a great way to try new products that I might not have ordered otherwise. Everything single thing in the box was a delight, including a gift wrapped Golden Tin! My lucky day!"

— Tim Z. (5/5)

Q&A

Follow

© 2026 Donostia Foods.

Amazon American Express Apple Pay Diners Club Discover Google Pay Mastercard Shop Pay Visa